Lately
I’ve been putting a lot of thought into how libraries and librarians
can challenge racism in higher education. It is a tricky thing to talk
to people about for a couple reasons. For one, a lot of people,
especially White people, think of racism exclusively as something that
is interpersonal, overt, and motivated by hate. It is not. While that
kind of racist behavior is less socially acceptable now than it was in
the past, less overt but equally harmful microaggressions are still
perpetrated against people of color on a daily basis. Look no further
than racist tweets, culturally appropriationist theme parties, or complaints against Affirmative Action.
Beyond
these often unacknowledged slights, the institution of higher education
in many ways still reflects and upholds the historic social and
economic dominance of White people in America. In a thorough and insightful review, Diane Lynn Gusa describes a pervasive White institutional presence
(WIP) at colleges and universities across the country. WIP manifests in
a sense of superiority and entitlement among Whites, which goes
hand-in-hand with monoculturalism of White culture, values, and beliefs.
We see this in the curriculum where White authors and culture are the
assumed normal, while other cultures are only addressed in separate
courses. What do you think it feels like to be an American and a Latina majoring in English these days
when authors of color are routinely excluded from “the canon”? Outside
of the classroom, Whiteness is equally pervasive: the social activities,
performers brought to campus, artwork, names on the buildings, and the
faculty and administration. In one study
by Mitzi Davis, et al. a student remarked: “A lot of time I feel out of
place, because you see all White faces. You know I am the only fly in
the buttermilk.” White members of these institutions often fail to
recognize the pervasive markers of their identity and their privilege,
while non-White members are distanced physically and socially from the
community.
Another
reason this conversation is difficult to have in the library community
is that we see ourselves as being progressive and welcoming communities.
Even if racism is taking place on our campuses, could we really be
perpetuating in our libraries? Yes, I think we are. Though
we may indeed be harboring a bunch of liberal malcontents, we are still
a place that reflects the norms of our communities, both good and bad.
Students can and do experience microaggressions, hostility, and negative
stereotypes relating to their use of the library. A study by Daniel Solorzano and Miguel Ceja quotes a student:
Last time we went to the library ... to study ... obviously, it's finals time ... people are going to study. But when we walked in there looking for somewhere to sit down, it's like ... they've never seen Black people before in their lives, or they've never seen Black people study before!
Another example is the now defunct Asians Sleeping in the Library tumblr (don’t worry, Buzzfeed archived selections of it for posterity).
It
is hard to say the extent of racism our students of color face because
this is an issue that we have not sufficiently researched or addressed.
However, the negative and alienating experiences of students of color on
college campuses has been researched, and I think it is naïve and lazy
to assume that the problems happening on our campuses are not happening
in our libraries. As a community that prides is progressive and
welcoming nature, it is time for us to address this head on.
